The short answer
The main alternatives to Thumbtack and Angi for contractors are Google Local Services Ads, local platforms like Yelp and Nextdoor, and the things you own outright: your Google Business Profile, your own website and your own ads. Thumbtack and Angi sell the same homeowner request to several pros. With your own channels, the request comes only to you.
Most contractors do best with a mix: a complete Google profile and a proper website as the base, their own ads for steady work, and a lead marketplace on top only if the numbers add up.
How Thumbtack and Angi charge
| Thumbtack | Angi (formerly HomeAdvisor) | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost to join | No joining, annual or membership fee | Not published. Pay per lead, or a subscription that renews automatically |
| What you pay for | Each lead, at a price you set for each service, up to a weekly budget | Each lead matched to you, whether or not you respond to it |
| Price list | None published. Your account shows your prices | None published. Fees vary by job, location and demand |
| Who else gets the lead | Several pros can contact the same customer | A request is matched with up to five pros |
This is how each platform described its own charges when we checked in November 2026. Terms change, so read the current pages and get anything unclear in writing before you commit.
Thumbtack and Angi alternatives compared
| Option | How you pay | Who gets the enquiry | What you keep if you stop |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thumbtack | Per lead, at a price you set | Several pros | Your reviews on their site |
| Angi | Per matched lead, or a subscription | Up to five pros | Your reviews on their site |
| Google Local Services Ads | Per valid lead. Leads Google judges invalid are not charged | The customer picks from the ads shown | Your Google reviews |
| Yelp Ads | A daily ad budget, with no term contract on self-serve | Your ad shows beside other businesses | Your Yelp page and reviews |
| Nextdoor | A free business page, with paid local ads on top | Neighbors see other local businesses too | Your page and recommendations |
| Houzz Pro | A subscription | People browsing the directory | Your profile and photos |
| Google Business Profile | Free | Only you | Everything: it is yours |
| Your own website | A setup fee and a monthly price. Ours is £99 then £9 a month | Only you | Everything: it is yours |
| Your own Facebook and Instagram ads | You pay the ad platform directly | Only you | The ad account, the audience and the leads |
Are Thumbtack and Angi worth it?
They can be. It depends on your cost per booked job, not your cost per lead.
- They tend to work when you reply within minutes, when the job is worth far more than the lead fee, and when you are new and have no reviews or Google presence yet.
- They tend not to when you are on a job and can’t answer fast, because the same request has gone to other pros and the first to reply usually wins.
The fair test: add up what you paid over 90 days and divide it by the jobs you actually booked from that platform. Compare that figure across every channel you use.
The closest swap: Google Local Services Ads
Local Services Ads put you at the very top of Google with a “Google Screened” or “Google Guaranteed” badge. Google says you pay for valid leads, and that leads it judges invalid or low quality are not charged. You have to pass Google’s screening first, and you set a weekly budget.
The difference from a marketplace is that the customer contacts you directly from your ad. They are not passed to a list of pros.
The alternative most contractors miss
When a homeowner needs a roofer or a plumber, most of them search Google first. Google shows three businesses on the map, then the websites underneath. Neither charges you per enquiry.
- Fill in your Google Business Profile properly. Every category, service, city, photo and opening hour. It is free, and it is the biggest single factor in showing up on Google Maps.
- Have a website with a page for every job and every city you cover. Someone searching “roof repair in Otley” is shown a page about exactly that.
- Run your own ads to your own page. A video of you and your crew, sent to a short quiz that asks the job, the timing and the postcode. Every lead is yours alone.
- Catch the calls you miss. A text back within seconds keeps the lead from ringing the next name.
That is what we set up. See lead generation for contractors, Facebook video ads, websites for contractors and local SEO.
Should you leave Thumbtack or Angi?
Not necessarily, and not all at once. Many contractors keep a marketplace running while their own website, profile and ads build up, then cut back once their own enquiries are steady. If you are on a subscription, check the renewal date and the cancellation terms first.








